Papa C Pies has Closed
We closed Papa C Pies Bakery on January 25, 2025. Thank you for 15 wonderful years of business. We enjoyed serving our community with handmade family recipe creations.
Read More Here!



OUR STORY


Founded in 2009, our family business owes our recipes and love of pie to Grandma Elsie Mae. My Grandmother always made the most delicious apple pies. One year during the holiday season, we asked her to write down her recipes. She couldn’t do it! She said she didn’t learn from a recipe – her mother taught her by making the pies with her.
My father – Papa C, for whom the bakery is named – learned to bake alongside Grandma Elsie and carried on the tradition by teaching me. Elsie always said, “You need to see and feel the ingredients come together” for the most delicious pie. When you make something often enough, and you love to make it, you don’t need a piece of paper to tell you how. You can get a taste of Elsie’s exceptional apple pie recipe today it’s the exact recipe for the classic Apple Pie on our menu! From this first recipe, many additional flavors have been added to the bakery’s menu of options. But they always start with premium, high-quality ingredients, just like Grandma Elsie would buy.
From our family to yours, we hope you enjoy our handmade pies!

Founded in 2009, our family business owes our recipes and love of pie to Grandma Elsie Mae. My Grandmother always made the most delicious apple pies. One year during the holiday season, we asked her to write down her recipes. She couldn’t do it! She said she didn’t learn from a recipe – her mother taught her by making the pies with her.
My father – Papa C, for whom the bakery is named – learned to bake alongside Grandma Elsie and carried on the tradition by teaching me. Elsie always said, “You need to see and feel the ingredients come together” for the most delicious pie. When you make something often enough, and you love to make it, you don’t need a piece of paper to tell you how. You can get a taste of Elsie’s exceptional apple pie recipe today it’s the exact recipe for the classic Apple Pie on our menu! From this first recipe, many additional flavors have been added to the bakery’s menu of options. But they always start with premium, high-quality ingredients, just like Grandma Elsie would buy.
From our family to yours, we hope you enjoy our handmade pies!

LATEST BLOGS & NEWS

Celebrate Mom with a Delicious Menu of Pies for Mother’s Day Brunch
Mother's Day celebrates the incredible women who fill our lives with love, warmth, and endless support. As we prepare to honor these remarkable individuals, one delightful tradition stands out: the...
Planning a Party this Spring? Consider Catering with Pies for the Ultimate Dessert Table
Pies symbolize comfort and celebration with their irresistible blend of flaky crusts and sumptuous fillings. Their versatility and crowd-pleasing flavors make them a stellar catering choice for any...
Perfectly Delicious Pies To Order For Your Easter Table
We’re hopping right into Spring with an early visit from the Easter bunny! It’s hard to believe that Easter is right around the corner, but the date falls early this year on Sunday, March 31st. As...
Three of Our Favorite Pies to Celebrate Pi Day on 3.14!
We celebrate many holidays with pie at Papa C Pies, but one of our favorite days of the year is Pi Day! It falls on March 14th every year (3.14 for anyone new to this mathematical figure) and is a...
Indulge in a Classic Pie Flavor: National Cherry Pie Day is February 20!
On February 20th each year, dessert lovers across the United States come together to celebrate a beloved classic: cherry pie. National Cherry Pie Day pays homage to this iconic American dessert,...
A Sweet Treat for Your Sweetheart: Pie Is the Perfect Way to Say “I Love You”
February brings the season of love to life! With heart decor exploding in retail shops, chocolate in every aisle of the grocery store, and dozens of email newsletters reminding you to buy gift...

CUSTOMER REVIEWS
