Papa C Pies has Closed
We closed Papa C Pies Bakery on January 25, 2025. Thank you for 15 wonderful years of business. We enjoyed serving our community with handmade family recipe creations.
Read More Here!



OUR STORY


Founded in 2009, our family business owes our recipes and love of pie to Grandma Elsie Mae. My Grandmother always made the most delicious apple pies. One year during the holiday season, we asked her to write down her recipes. She couldn’t do it! She said she didn’t learn from a recipe – her mother taught her by making the pies with her.
My father – Papa C, for whom the bakery is named – learned to bake alongside Grandma Elsie and carried on the tradition by teaching me. Elsie always said, “You need to see and feel the ingredients come together” for the most delicious pie. When you make something often enough, and you love to make it, you don’t need a piece of paper to tell you how. You can get a taste of Elsie’s exceptional apple pie recipe today it’s the exact recipe for the classic Apple Pie on our menu! From this first recipe, many additional flavors have been added to the bakery’s menu of options. But they always start with premium, high-quality ingredients, just like Grandma Elsie would buy.
From our family to yours, we hope you enjoy our handmade pies!

Founded in 2009, our family business owes our recipes and love of pie to Grandma Elsie Mae. My Grandmother always made the most delicious apple pies. One year during the holiday season, we asked her to write down her recipes. She couldn’t do it! She said she didn’t learn from a recipe – her mother taught her by making the pies with her.
My father – Papa C, for whom the bakery is named – learned to bake alongside Grandma Elsie and carried on the tradition by teaching me. Elsie always said, “You need to see and feel the ingredients come together” for the most delicious pie. When you make something often enough, and you love to make it, you don’t need a piece of paper to tell you how. You can get a taste of Elsie’s exceptional apple pie recipe today it’s the exact recipe for the classic Apple Pie on our menu! From this first recipe, many additional flavors have been added to the bakery’s menu of options. But they always start with premium, high-quality ingredients, just like Grandma Elsie would buy.
From our family to yours, we hope you enjoy our handmade pies!

LATEST BLOGS & NEWS

Stand Out From the Crowd with Corporate Gifting From Papa C Pies
In a sea of corporate gifts, it's hard to find something that leaves a lasting impression. Branded pens, mugs, and baskets may have their place, but why not gift something everyone will love? When...
Celebrate Pumpkin Pie Day on October 12 with a Delicious Slice from Papa C Pies
Fall is in full swing, and there’s no better way to embrace the season than by indulging in one of its most iconic pie flavors: pumpkin pie. As the leaves turn golden and the air becomes crisp, mark...
Calling Pumpkin Spice Fans: Fall Pies Have Launched at Papa C Pies
As the crisp air of fall rolls in and the leaves begin to turn, there’s no better way to celebrate the season than with comforting, seasonal desserts. This year, Papa C Pies is excited to announce...
Pot Pie Is the Perfect Dish for Family Night!
Celebrate National Pot Pie Day on September 23 with the perfect dish for family night – Papa C Pies’ Pot Pie! When it comes to family night, nothing says comfort like gathering around the table...
Celebrate Lemon Pie Day with a Lemon Icebox Pie from Papa C Pies!
August 15th is the tartest pie holiday of the year: National Lemon Pie Day! If the bright flavor of lemon is one of your favorite treats, then make sure to plan a visit to Papa C Pies on National...
Rock Your Back-to-School Teacher Gift with Individually Wrapped Pie Tarts!
The gift of an apple is so last year! At Papa C Pies, the bakery freshly bakes various room-temperature and icebox-style pie tarts daily to please any teacher’s taste buds. Here are some of our...

CUSTOMER REVIEWS
