Papa C Pies has Closed
We closed Papa C Pies Bakery on January 25, 2025. Thank you for 15 wonderful years of business. We enjoyed serving our community with handmade family recipe creations.
Read More Here!



OUR STORY


Founded in 2009, our family business owes our recipes and love of pie to Grandma Elsie Mae. My Grandmother always made the most delicious apple pies. One year during the holiday season, we asked her to write down her recipes. She couldn’t do it! She said she didn’t learn from a recipe – her mother taught her by making the pies with her.
My father – Papa C, for whom the bakery is named – learned to bake alongside Grandma Elsie and carried on the tradition by teaching me. Elsie always said, “You need to see and feel the ingredients come together” for the most delicious pie. When you make something often enough, and you love to make it, you don’t need a piece of paper to tell you how. You can get a taste of Elsie’s exceptional apple pie recipe today it’s the exact recipe for the classic Apple Pie on our menu! From this first recipe, many additional flavors have been added to the bakery’s menu of options. But they always start with premium, high-quality ingredients, just like Grandma Elsie would buy.
From our family to yours, we hope you enjoy our handmade pies!

Founded in 2009, our family business owes our recipes and love of pie to Grandma Elsie Mae. My Grandmother always made the most delicious apple pies. One year during the holiday season, we asked her to write down her recipes. She couldn’t do it! She said she didn’t learn from a recipe – her mother taught her by making the pies with her.
My father – Papa C, for whom the bakery is named – learned to bake alongside Grandma Elsie and carried on the tradition by teaching me. Elsie always said, “You need to see and feel the ingredients come together” for the most delicious pie. When you make something often enough, and you love to make it, you don’t need a piece of paper to tell you how. You can get a taste of Elsie’s exceptional apple pie recipe today it’s the exact recipe for the classic Apple Pie on our menu! From this first recipe, many additional flavors have been added to the bakery’s menu of options. But they always start with premium, high-quality ingredients, just like Grandma Elsie would buy.
From our family to yours, we hope you enjoy our handmade pies!

LATEST BLOGS & NEWS

Nothing Says “Comfort” Like a Savory Pie on a Chilly Night!
Nothing Says “Comfort” Like a Savory Pie on a Chilly Night! DECEMBER 10, 2020 The early nights mean crisp evenings that can sometimes chill you right to the bone. You’re exhausted and cold from all...
The Great Pie Crust Debate… Crumb or Pastry?
The Great Pie Crust Debate… Crumb or Pastry? JANUARY 25, 2021 Remember when Mary Poppins mentioned a “pie crust promise,” easily made, easily broken? When she said easily made, did she mean a crumb...
Savory Pie: The Perfect Choice for Dinner
Savory Pie: The Perfect Choice for Dinner JANUARY 29, 2021 Recently overheard, from husband to wife: “No offense, sweetie. I used to think your quiche was really good! But this… oh my gosh!” Wife...
Celebrate Pies All February Long: It’s National Pie Month!
Celebrate Pies All February Long: It’s National Pie Month! FEBRUARY 22, 2021 You missed National Pie Day (January 23rd) and National Pi Day (March 14) is too far away. Papa C Pies feels the same...
The Four Most Sought After Pies
The Four Most Sought After Pies MARCH 1, 2021 Picking a favorite pie would be as difficult as choosing a favorite child or parent. So we won’t even ask. After all, it depends on your mood, the time...
Celebrate Pi Day: 14 Faves of the Ultimate Circular Food… PIE
Celebrate Pi Day: 14 Faves of the Ultimate Circular Food… PIE MARCH 11, 2021 Pi is a mathematical constant, the relationship between the circumference and diameter of any given circle. What better...

CUSTOMER REVIEWS
